Why, Carlisle??
Okay, so I finish New Moon for the second time yesterday, right? And I wonder, yet again, WHAT is up with Carlisle's reaction (or lack thereof) to seeing Edward safe and sound, fresh from Italy!?
"'Thank you, Bella,' Carlisle said. 'We owe you.'"
...Not one exclamation point or italicized word - he doesn't even say anything to Edward! Esme made me happy inside; she reacted like a mother would. Carlisle seemed to have more of a faintly-concerned-friend-of-the-family kind of gratitude. Carlisle created Edward, he's his father, "in so many real ways" as Bella puts it. Edward was Carlisle's first companion, and they supposedly have an extremely deep bond going on. Can't blame Carlisle, of course - he's only Stephenie Meyer's puppet. I suppose the real question should be directed toward Mrs. Meyer, as the author....
It irks me.
Apparently, I'm not the only one to be bothered by this - I read one piece of fan fiction called The Chasm by fwuzzfwuzz that attempts to explain the possible thought processes behind Carlisle's less-than-satisfying reaction. I think I've been inspired to write a similar one myself....I just really love familial parent-child relationships between unrelated people. I absolutely inhale those moments that apply. Perhaps that's why I'm so attracted to Harry Potter and his fandom - plenty of poor orphan/adoption material there. =P
Rant aside, I have exciting (though probably thoroughly inconsequential to anyone else) news! I have now mastered the Rubik's cube. I know. Earth shattering, right? Well, it was for me. I could taste the sense of accomplishment in the air....
Well anyway, signing off to go start Eclipse. Maybe there'll be some good Carlisle-Edward interaction that I forgot about.
It's okay, Edward - I care that the Volturi didn't get a chance to tear you to pieces....
"'Thank you, Bella,' Carlisle said. 'We owe you.'"
...Not one exclamation point or italicized word - he doesn't even say anything to Edward! Esme made me happy inside; she reacted like a mother would. Carlisle seemed to have more of a faintly-concerned-friend-of-the-family kind of gratitude. Carlisle created Edward, he's his father, "in so many real ways" as Bella puts it. Edward was Carlisle's first companion, and they supposedly have an extremely deep bond going on. Can't blame Carlisle, of course - he's only Stephenie Meyer's puppet. I suppose the real question should be directed toward Mrs. Meyer, as the author....
It irks me.
Apparently, I'm not the only one to be bothered by this - I read one piece of fan fiction called The Chasm by fwuzzfwuzz that attempts to explain the possible thought processes behind Carlisle's less-than-satisfying reaction. I think I've been inspired to write a similar one myself....I just really love familial parent-child relationships between unrelated people. I absolutely inhale those moments that apply. Perhaps that's why I'm so attracted to Harry Potter and his fandom - plenty of poor orphan/adoption material there. =P
Rant aside, I have exciting (though probably thoroughly inconsequential to anyone else) news! I have now mastered the Rubik's cube. I know. Earth shattering, right? Well, it was for me. I could taste the sense of accomplishment in the air....
Well anyway, signing off to go start Eclipse. Maybe there'll be some good Carlisle-Edward interaction that I forgot about.
It's okay, Edward - I care that the Volturi didn't get a chance to tear you to pieces....

mellow